Chapter One: An Unfortunate Announcement
By half past three on Thursday afternoon, Jessica Marsh had sold a chipped porcelain spaniel, offended a man from Ohio, and discovered that the roof above her stockroom was leaking again. None of these developments was particularly unusual, although she had hoped the roof might wait until after Christmas before demanding another contribution to its ongoing restoration fund.
She stood in the doorway of the stockroom, studying the dark patch spreading across the ceiling. The previous night’s rain had been heavy, but Savannah had enjoyed a perfectly respectable morning, and Jessica considered it unreasonable for the building to continue dripping long after the weather had improved.
A large copper preserving pan sat beneath the leak. She had positioned it there in September, when the roofer assured her that the problem had been fixed, and had left it in place because experience suggested that optimism was a poor substitute for practical arrangements.
Behind her, someone cleared his throat.
“Excuse me. Is anybody working here?”
Jessica turned to find a gentleman standing beside the counter, holding a silver-plated candlestick with the suspicious expression of someone who had just discovered a dead insect in his soup.
“That depends,” she said. “Are you buying something or preparing to tell me it’s cheaper on the internet?”
He looked momentarily offended, which Jessica considered a reasonable improvement on his original expression.
“I was wondering whether this is genuine silver.”
“Silver plate. Early twentieth century, probably English. The mark’s underneath.”
He turned the candlestick over and examined it.
“What’s the difference?”
“About three hundred dollars, in this particular case.”
The man gave a reluctant smile. “Fair enough.”
Jessica returned to the counter and showed him the manufacturer’s mark, explaining how the plating had worn along the raised decoration and why the small dent near the base was unlikely to affect its usefulness. He listened with more interest than she’d expected, eventually purchasing the candlestick and a matching tray that had been gathering dust since February.
By the time he left, Jessica had revised her opinion of him considerably. She had also made enough money to pay the electrician, which was fortunate because he had telephoned twice that morning.
Marsh House Antiques occupied the ground floor of a narrow brick building on a side street not far from Savannah’s historic district. The shop had tall windows, uneven wooden floors, and a front door that stuck whenever the humidity rose above a level Jessica considered personally offensive. Inside, furniture from several centuries competed for space with glass cabinets, framed photographs, old books, and the peculiar assortment of objects people accumulated before discovering that their children had no intention of inheriting them.
Jessica had owned the business for nineteen years. Before that, she had worked for a local auction house, where she learned that the value of an object depended as much on the person selling it as the person buying it. She had also learned to recognize the difference between genuine antiques and furniture that had been attacked with sandpaper in an attempt to make it look interesting.
At fifty-two, she still enjoyed the work, although she had grown less enthusiastic about carrying wardrobes upstairs and explaining to tourists why a hundred-year-old chair was not necessarily comfortable.
She crossed to the front window and adjusted a small display of silver picture frames. Beyond the glass, the afternoon sunlight filtered through the branches of the live oaks, illuminating patches of pavement and the wrought-iron railings across the street. A couple wandered past with a map, arguing cheerfully about which direction would take them to the river. Somewhere nearby, a delivery truck was reversing with an electronic warning that sounded like a distressed bird.
Savannah was beautiful in October. The worst of the summer heat had usually retreated, leaving warm afternoons, cooler evenings, and the occasional thunderstorm that seemed determined to remind everyone who was in charge. Jessica had lived there long enough to appreciate the city’s beauty without feeling obliged to admire it every time she went outside.
She was rearranging a set of porcelain cups when her telephone rang.
The display showed an unfamiliar number.
“Marsh House Antiques, Jessica speaking.”
“Mrs. Marsh? This is Angela at Whitfield Property Services. I’m calling about the house on Wisteria Lane.”
Jessica closed her eyes.
Of all the subjects she had hoped to avoid that afternoon, Wisteria Lane occupied a position somewhere between dental surgery and an unexpected visit from the tax authorities.
“What about it?”
“We’ve had another inquiry.”
“From a buyer?”
“Not exactly. A gentleman contacted us asking whether the property was available to view.”
“That sounds rather like a buyer.”
“He said he was acting on behalf of someone else.”
Jessica waited.
Angela lowered her voice, although Jessica couldn’t imagine who might be listening at the property office.
“He also asked whether the mirrors were still inside.”
Jessica stopped moving.
“The mirrors?”
“Yes. Apparently he was interested in the original fixtures.”
“There aren’t any original mirrors left in the house.”
“That’s what I told him.”
“Did he give you his name?”
“Mr. Hargrove. I think. He spoke very softly.”
Jessica looked toward the large gilded mirror hanging above the shop’s fireplace. It was a perfectly ordinary nineteenth-century piece, purchased from an estate sale in Charleston, but she found herself examining its reflection more carefully than usual.
“Did he leave a number?”
“No. He said he’d call again.”
“Well, if he does, tell him the property isn’t available for viewing until I’ve arranged another inspection.”
“Of course. And, Jessica?”
“Yes?”
“I’m sorry to bring this up, but the council has written again about the condition of the garden.”
Jessica sighed.
“Tell them I’ll have someone deal with it.”
After ending the call, she remained behind the counter for a moment, considering the house on Wisteria Lane.
It had belonged to her late husband’s family for more than a century. Thomas had inherited it from his grandmother shortly before their marriage, along with several pieces of furniture, a collection of family papers, and a considerable amount of resentment toward a woman who had apparently regarded affection as an unnecessary expense.
For years, the house had stood empty. Jessica had tried to sell it after Thomas died, but the first buyer withdrew following a survey, the second discovered a problem with the title deeds, and the third changed his mind without offering any explanation.
Eventually, she had stopped trying.
The property cost her money, but selling it would require returning to a place she had avoided for eleven years.
And Jessica had become remarkably accomplished at avoiding things.
She opened the drawer beneath the register and took out a small notebook containing the telephone numbers of local tradespeople. Halfway through searching for the gardener, she noticed a folded photograph tucked between the pages.
It showed Caroline at eight years old, standing beneath the magnolia tree in their old backyard. Her dark hair was tied into two untidy braids, and she was holding a ginger kitten with the determined expression of a child who had already decided the animal was staying.
Jessica sat down.
The photograph had been taken on Caroline’s birthday, a week before the accident that left the small scar above her eyebrow. Thomas had spent the afternoon assembling a bicycle while Caroline supervised, and Jessica remembered laughing because the instructions were in German and her husband insisted that diagrams were universal.
For a moment, she could almost hear them.
Thomas’s exasperated voice.
Caroline’s delighted laughter.
The ordinary sounds of a family that had not yet learned how fragile ordinary happiness could be.
Jessica traced the edge of the photograph with her thumb.
Six months.
That was how long it had been since she’d heard her daughter’s voice.
The police continued to describe Caroline as a missing adult who might have left voluntarily. Her apartment had been undisturbed, her car was gone, and there was no evidence of violence. They had checked hospitals, interviewed friends, and examined what financial records they could obtain.
Nothing suggested that Caroline had been harmed.
Nothing suggested that she was safe, either.
Jessica had spent the first month telephoning everyone she could think of, the second driving to places Caroline might have visited, and the third becoming so familiar with the police station that one of the receptionists began keeping peppermint tea for her.
By the fourth month, people had started telling her that she needed to look after herself.
Jessica had found this advice spectacularly unhelpful.
She put the photograph back in the notebook, but left the drawer open.
Caroline had always been closer to Thomas. As a child, she followed him around the house asking questions about everything from the workings of the dishwasher to why the moon sometimes appeared during the day. He answered with endless patience, inventing elaborate explanations when he didn’t know the truth.
Jessica had been the practical parent. She remembered permission slips, dentist appointments, school uniforms, and the fact that Caroline disliked tomatoes unless they had been turned into sauce.
After Thomas died, that difference became a distance neither of them seemed able to cross.
Caroline wanted to talk about him.
Jessica wanted to keep moving.
By the time they understood what was happening, their conversations had become careful exchanges about work, the weather, and whether either of them needed anything from the grocery store.
Their last argument had been about Wisteria Lane.
Caroline wanted to go through the family papers stored there. She had become convinced that Thomas’s grandmother had hidden something important, although she refused to explain what she expected to find.
Jessica had told her to leave the past alone.
Caroline accused her of being afraid.
Jessica accused Caroline of inventing mysteries because she couldn’t accept that her father was gone.
Neither had apologized.
Three days later, Caroline disappeared.
The memory still had the power to make Jessica feel ashamed.
She closed the drawer and returned to work.
At five fifteen, Jessica locked the shop’s front door and turned the sign to CLOSED. She had stayed later than intended, partly because of the stockroom leak and partly because she disliked returning to an empty house before evening had properly arrived.
Her home was a small two-story property about fifteen minutes away, with a screened porch, a garden that had gradually surrendered to weeds, and a kitchen table that was far too large for one person.
She had considered moving several times.
Each time, she found a reason not to.
The radio behind the counter was playing an old country song. Jessica turned up the volume while she counted the day’s receipts and completed the handwritten ledger she continued to maintain despite the accountant’s repeated assurances that computers had become quite reliable.
She was entering the candlestick sale when the music ended.
A cheerful announcer began reading the local community notices.
Jessica listened without particular interest as he mentioned a charity luncheon, a historical society meeting, and an upcoming exhibition at a gallery on Broughton Street.
Then he said her name.
“At eleven tomorrow morning, a memorial service will be held for Jessica Anne Marsh, a longtime Savannah resident and proprietor of Marsh House Antiques.”
Jessica’s pen stopped moving.
The announcer continued in the same pleasant tone.
“Mrs. Marsh, fifty-two, was the widow of the late Thomas Marsh and is survived by her daughter, Caroline. Friends and acquaintances are invited to attend the service at Bellamy Funeral Home on Abercorn Street.”
There was a short pause before he moved on to an advertisement for a local roofing company.
Jessica stared at the radio.
She had heard every word clearly, but her mind seemed unwilling to arrange them into a sensible explanation.
For several seconds, she remained perfectly still.
Then she reached across the counter and switched it off.
The silence felt unusually complete.
She looked down at her ledger, where she’d written the date beside the day’s takings. Thursday, October 22.
Tomorrow was Friday.
Tomorrow, apparently, she was being buried.
Jessica leaned back in her chair.
“Well,” she said eventually, “someone’s made a rather serious mistake.”
She picked up her telephone and searched for Bellamy Funeral Home.
The receptionist answered promptly.
“Bellamy Funeral Home. Rebecca speaking. How may I help you?”
“Good afternoon, Rebecca. My name is Jessica Marsh, and I’ve just heard a rather surprising announcement on the radio.”
“Yes, ma’am?”
“Apparently you’re holding my funeral tomorrow.”
There was a pause.
“I’m sorry, could you repeat that?”
“Certainly. My funeral. Tomorrow morning. Eleven o’clock.”
Another pause followed.
“May I ask your relationship to the deceased?”
Jessica looked toward the ceiling.
“I am the deceased.”
“I see.”
“I rather doubt that you do.”
The receptionist apologized and asked her to hold.
Jessica listened to a recorded arrangement of Amazing Grace while examining a small crack in the plaster above the register. She had never liked that hymn particularly, and hearing it while waiting to discuss her own funeral did nothing to improve her opinion.
After nearly three minutes, a man came on the line.
“Mrs. Marsh? This is William Bellamy. I’m the funeral director.”
“Good afternoon, Mr. Bellamy.”
“I understand there’s been some confusion.”
“I certainly hope so.”
“Would you mind telling me exactly what you heard?”
Jessica repeated the announcement.
Bellamy listened without interrupting.
When she finished, he was quiet for so long that she wondered whether the call had disconnected.
“Mr. Bellamy?”
“Yes. I’m here.”
“Then perhaps you could explain why you’re arranging a funeral for a woman who is currently standing in her antique shop, feeling rather inconvenienced by the whole business.”
“I think it would be best if you came to see me.”
“Why?”
“There are some details I’d prefer to discuss in person.”
“Surely you can tell me whether you have a body.”
Another silence.
Jessica felt the first genuine unease of the afternoon.
“Mr. Bellamy?”
“Yes,” he said quietly. “We do.”
She looked toward the front windows.
Outside, the last sunlight had turned the buildings opposite a warm shade of gold. A young couple walked past holding hands, and a cyclist rang his bell at someone who had stepped into the street without looking.
Everything appeared entirely normal.
“Whose body?” Jessica asked.
Bellamy cleared his throat.
“Mrs. Marsh, I really think you should come here.”
She considered arguing.
Under ordinary circumstances, she would have insisted on an explanation before going anywhere. But the announcement had included details that could not reasonably have been confused with those of another woman.
Her name.
Her business.
Thomas.
Caroline.
And Caroline’s name troubled her more than anything else.
“Who made the arrangements?” she asked.
Bellamy hesitated.
“Your daughter.”
Jessica felt her grip tighten around the telephone.
“My daughter?”
“Yes, ma’am.”
“Caroline Marsh?”
“That is the name on the paperwork.”
Jessica sat down.
For six months, she had waited for someone to tell her where Caroline was.
Now a funeral director was calmly informing her that her daughter had arranged a burial.
“Mr. Bellamy, I need you to listen carefully. My daughter has been missing since April. If she’s been in contact with you, I need to know when and how.”
His voice changed.
“Missing?”
“Yes.”
“I wasn’t aware.”
“Clearly.”
He asked her to come to the funeral home as soon as possible.
Jessica agreed, collected her handbag, and switched off the remaining lights. She checked the back door twice, although she couldn’t have explained why, and stood for a moment beside the counter, trying to remember whether she’d forgotten anything.
Her eyes fell on the photograph of Caroline, still visible through the half-open drawer.
She took it out and slipped it into her handbag.
Then she left.
Bellamy Funeral Home stood on a quiet stretch of Abercorn Street, occupying a handsome nineteenth-century building with white columns and a broad veranda. Its windows glowed warmly against the approaching evening, and the garden was so carefully maintained that Jessica suspected the gardeners had been instructed to remove individual leaves before they reached the ground.
She parked beneath a live oak and remained in her car for a moment.
The building was familiar.
She had attended two services there over the years, including that of a former neighbor who had lived to ninety-seven and left behind three husbands, four children, and a remarkable collection of unpaid parking tickets.
Jessica had never imagined arriving to investigate her own funeral.
She checked her reflection in the rearview mirror.
Her dark hair had escaped its clip, and there was a faint streak of dust on the sleeve of her blouse. She considered brushing it away, then decided that a woman attending a meeting about her own death was entitled to look slightly disheveled.
Inside, the reception hall smelled of lilies and furniture polish.
A woman behind the desk looked up as Jessica entered.
“Good evening. May I help you?”
“I’m Jessica Marsh. Mr. Bellamy is expecting me.”
The receptionist’s expression changed so abruptly that Jessica knew she had found Rebecca.
“Oh.”
“Yes,” Jessica said. “That seems to be the general reaction.”
Rebecca rose from her chair.
“Would you excuse me for just a moment?”
She disappeared through a doorway.
Jessica waited beside a small table displaying brochures about memorial arrangements. One promised A Celebration of a Life Well Lived. Another offered advice on choosing the perfect tribute.
She was considering whether anyone had asked about her preferences when a man emerged from the hallway.
William Bellamy was tall and slender, with carefully combed silver hair and the composed expression of someone accustomed to delivering difficult news. He wore a charcoal suit and a dark blue tie, and his shoes were polished to a degree Jessica found faintly excessive.
He stopped when he saw her.
For a moment, his face lost every trace of professional composure.
“Mrs. Marsh?”
Jessica held out her hand.
“I’m afraid so.”
He shook it automatically.
His fingers were cold.
“Would you come into my office?”
She followed him down a corridor lined with tasteful landscape paintings and framed photographs of the building in earlier decades. Bellamy’s office overlooked the rear garden, where the branches of an enormous oak brushed against the windows.
He offered her a seat and closed the door.
Jessica placed her handbag on her lap.
“Now,” she said, “perhaps we can establish exactly how this happened.”
Bellamy sat behind his desk.
“I’ve been reviewing the arrangements since we spoke.”
“And?”
“The paperwork appears to be in order.”
Jessica stared at him.
“Mr. Bellamy, I’m sitting in front of you.”
“Yes. I appreciate that.”
“Then surely the paperwork is wrong.”
He rubbed his forehead.
“I don’t know how to explain this.”
“Try starting at the beginning.”
He opened a folder.
“On Monday afternoon, a young woman came here to arrange a funeral for her mother. She identified herself as Caroline Marsh.”
Jessica leaned forward.
“Was she alone?”
“Yes.”
“What did she look like?”
Bellamy described a woman in her early thirties with dark brown hair, a narrow face, and a small scar above her left eyebrow.
Jessica listened without moving.
“Did she seem upset?”
“She was very quiet. Exhausted, perhaps. She told me her mother had died unexpectedly and wanted a simple service.”
“Where was the body?”
“She arranged for it to be transferred from a private residence.”
“Which residence?”
Bellamy glanced at the paperwork.
“Fourteen Wisteria Lane.”
Jessica felt a cold sensation settle beneath her ribs.
The house.
Of course it was the house.
She had spent eleven years avoiding it, and now it seemed determined to involve itself in every part of her life.
“Did Caroline give you a telephone number?”
“No.”
“An address?”
“Only Wisteria Lane.”
“Did she say where she’d been for the last six months?”
Bellamy shook his head.
“I had no reason to ask.”
Jessica understood that. She didn’t like it, but she understood.
“May I see the paperwork?”
He hesitated.
Then he turned the folder toward her.
The signature at the bottom of the first page was Caroline’s.
Jessica recognized the looping C, the slightly uneven spacing, and the peculiar way her daughter crossed the final letter of her surname.
She had seen that handwriting on birthday cards, school assignments, and the occasional note left on the kitchen counter.
For a moment, she couldn’t speak.
Bellamy watched her carefully.
“Mrs. Marsh, perhaps you should contact the police.”
“I will.”
She turned another page.
The death certificate contained her full name, date of birth, and home address.
She examined it more closely.
The document looked official, but the physician’s name was unfamiliar, and the place of death was listed simply as a private residence.
“Who signed this?”
“A Dr. Nathaniel Price.”
“Do you know him?”
“No. The documents were supplied by your daughter.”
Jessica looked up.
“And you accepted them?”
Bellamy’s expression tightened.
“They appeared genuine.”
She considered arguing, but her attention had returned to the address.
Fourteen Wisteria Lane.
She had last entered that house eleven years earlier, shortly after Thomas’s funeral. Caroline had been nineteen then, grieving in a way Jessica hadn’t known how to help.
Jessica remembered finding her daughter upstairs, standing in the hallway outside the locked bedroom that had once belonged to Thomas’s grandmother.
Caroline had been speaking softly.
Jessica assumed she was on the telephone.
When she asked who she was talking to, Caroline looked at her with an expression Jessica had never forgotten.
“Grandma Augusta,” she’d said.
Augusta Marsh had been dead for nearly thirty years.
Jessica had dismissed the incident as grief.
She had dismissed many things as grief.
“Mrs. Marsh?”
Bellamy’s voice brought her back.
Jessica closed the folder.
“I want to see her.”
He looked confused.
“Your daughter?”
“The woman you’re planning to bury.”
Bellamy sat very still.
“I don’t think that would be advisable.”
Jessica felt her patience finally begin to fail.
“Mr. Bellamy, you have a body downstairs that you’ve identified as me. My missing daughter apparently delivered it from a house I’ve spent eleven years trying to forget. I think we’ve moved rather beyond what’s advisable.”
He looked toward the office door.
Then he rose.
“Very well.”
The viewing room was softly lit, with pale walls, heavy curtains, and arrangements of white flowers placed around a polished wooden coffin.
Jessica had expected to feel frightened.
Instead, she found herself oddly attentive to the details. The flowers were fresh. The coffin was expensive. Someone had chosen a dark green dress that looked almost identical to one Jessica had owned twenty years earlier.
Bellamy remained near the doorway.
Jessica approached the coffin slowly.
The woman lying inside had dark hair, carefully arranged around her shoulders. Her hands rested over a small bouquet of roses, and her face had the peaceful, slightly unfamiliar appearance that Jessica associated with funeral homes.
At first, Jessica thought she was looking at someone who resembled her.
Then she moved closer.
The woman had the same slightly crooked nose, the same faint lines beside her mouth, and the small pale scar near her chin that Jessica had acquired when she was twelve.
Jessica had never told anyone about that scar.
She had been climbing over a fence at her grandparents’ farm, slipped, and caught her chin on a rusty nail. Her mother had been furious, mostly because Jessica had been wearing her best Sunday dress.
She touched her own chin.
The woman in the coffin had the identical mark.
Jessica looked at Bellamy.
“Who is she?”
He said nothing.
Jessica turned back to the body.
The woman’s right hand rested above the flowers.
On her ring finger was a narrow gold band.
Jessica recognized it immediately.
Thomas had given her the ring on their wedding day.
She had stopped wearing it after his death, unable to bear the small daily reminder of everything she’d lost.
She had put it in her jewelry box after his death and had not thought to look for it in months.
Jessica leaned closer.
Inside the band, just visible beneath the light, were the words Thomas had chosen.
Forever, even after.
Her throat tightened.
She remembered laughing when he showed her the inscription, telling him that it sounded suspiciously like a threat.
He had kissed her and said that she was stuck with him.
For twenty-eight years, she had believed him.
Jessica straightened slowly.
“Mr. Bellamy.”
“Yes?”
“Where did you say my daughter brought this woman from?”
“Fourteen Wisteria Lane.”
She looked at the dead woman’s face again.
There was something else.
Something she hadn’t noticed at first.
The woman’s hair was arranged neatly across her forehead, but a few strands had fallen away from her temple.
Jessica leaned forward.
Beneath the hairline was a small crescent-shaped birthmark.
She knew that mark.
It belonged to Caroline.
Jessica reached for the edge of the coffin, steadying herself.
The woman lying before her had Jessica’s face, Thomas’s wedding ring, and Caroline’s birthmark.
And suddenly the possibility of a simple mistake seemed very far away.
Behind her, Bellamy moved toward the door.
“Mrs. Marsh, are you all right?”
Jessica barely heard him.
She was looking at the dead woman’s hands.
One finger had shifted against the flowers.
It was such a small movement that she might have imagined it.
Then the woman’s eyes opened.
Jessica stepped backward.
The dead woman looked directly at her.
And in a voice that sounded exactly like Jessica’s own, she whispered:
“Don’t let her bury me.”




