Caroline had first encountered the name while sorting through boxes of Thomas’s papers.
She had been helping Jessica clear out an old storage unit, and among the files she’d taken home was a folder of correspondence relating to Wisteria Lane. Most of it concerned ordinary estate matters, but one letter from Henry Wescott referred to an agreement that Thomas had apparently refused to honor.
“I thought it was about money,” Caroline said. “Some old family obligation. Dad had always hated discussing the house, so I assumed there was a dispute he’d never told us about.”
“Why didn’t you ask me?”
“I did.”
Jessica frowned.
“When?”
“Last Christmas. I asked whether Dad had ever mentioned an agreement with the Wescotts.”
Jessica searched her memory.
They had been in the kitchen, preparing dinner. Caroline had been sitting at the table with a stack of papers, and Jessica remembered telling her that she knew very little about Thomas’s family’s legal affairs.
“I thought you meant the estate,” Jessica said.
“I know.”
Caroline turned her glass slowly between her hands.
“I contacted Henry after that. He was perfectly pleasant until I mentioned Margaret Bell.”
Jessica remembered the name in Caroline’s notebook.
“He told you to leave it alone?”
“He told me Margaret had worked for the family many years ago and that anything concerning her was private.”
“That sounds like Henry.”
“He also said Dad had dealt with the matter before he died.”
Jessica looked toward the window.
She could picture Henry Wescott perfectly: silver-haired, carefully dressed, and unfailingly courteous in a way that often made disagreement seem like a breach of etiquette.
Thomas had never particularly liked him.
At the time, Jessica had assumed it was because Henry reminded him too much of his grandmother.
“Caroline, what made you keep looking?”
Her daughter hesitated.
“Something Dad said when I was seventeen.”
Jessica listened.
Caroline explained that she’d found an old photograph of a woman standing beside Augusta Marsh in the garden. Thomas had been unusually upset when she asked who the woman was. He’d taken the photograph away and told her not to go through his grandmother’s things again.
“He wasn’t angry exactly,” Caroline said. “He seemed frightened. I remember that more than anything.”
Jessica thought of Thomas’s final years, of the occasions when he’d become quiet after visiting Wisteria Lane.
“He told me the woman had suffered enough,” Caroline continued. “I didn’t understand what he meant.”
“And you think she was Margaret?”
“I know she was.”
Caroline reached into her bag and removed a photograph.
Jessica recognized it from the notebooks.
Margaret Bell stood on the veranda at Wisteria Lane, wearing a long skirt and pale blouse. Beside her was a younger Thomas, perhaps twenty-five or twenty-six, his hair longer than Jessica remembered.
Jessica studied his face.
He looked serious, almost troubled.
She had seen photographs from this period of his life before. In most of them, Thomas was laughing, surrounded by friends or leaning against his battered old car.
This was different.
“Where did you find it?”
“In a box at the house.”
Jessica turned the photograph over.
There was no date, only a name written in Thomas’s handwriting.
Margaret.
She examined the woman’s face.
The resemblance to the figure she’d seen in the coffin was unsettling, but it wasn’t exact. Margaret’s features were narrower, and her eyes were set slightly farther apart.
“She’s not identical to me,” Jessica said.
“No.”
“Then something happened between this photograph and yesterday.”
Caroline nodded.
Jessica set the photograph on the table.
“Tell me what you saw, Caroline. Not what you think it means. What actually happened.”
Her daughter looked relieved by the question.
“I went to Wisteria Lane in April. I’d found the key among Dad’s papers, and I wanted to look through the upstairs rooms. I thought there might be more letters.”
She paused.
“The little sitting room at the back of the house was locked. I remembered it from when I was a child, but I couldn’t find a key for it anywhere.”
Jessica remembered the room. Thomas had always kept it closed, saying the floorboards were unsafe.
“One afternoon, I heard someone moving inside.”
Jessica looked up.
“I thought it was an animal at first,” Caroline said. “Then someone spoke.”
“What did she say?”
“She asked whether Thomas had come back.”
Jessica felt a familiar ache.
Caroline described forcing the old lock and finding a woman sitting beside the window. Margaret had been thin, her dark hair streaked with gray, and she’d appeared bewildered by the sound of traffic outside.
“She knew my name,” Caroline said. “She remembered me from when I was little.”
Jessica stared at her.
“You’re saying she was living in that room?”
“Yes.”
“For how long?”
“I don’t know. She couldn’t always remember.”
“Who was looking after her?”
Caroline’s expression darkened.
“Henry.”
Jessica sat back.
“He brought food and supplies. She said he’d been doing it for years, although sometimes she couldn’t remember how long he’d been gone.”
Jessica thought of the locked room, the neglected house, and the old lawyer who had insisted there was nothing left to discuss.
A terrible anger began to take shape.
“Did you tell anyone?”
“I tried to persuade her to come with me. She wouldn’t. She said Thomas had warned her that leaving could kill her.”
Jessica looked down at the photograph.
“And you believed her?”
“Not at first. I thought she was confused, perhaps suffering from some kind of illness. But she knew things about Dad that she couldn’t have learned from the photographs.”
“Such as?”
Caroline smiled faintly.
“She knew he used to hide his report cards behind the loose panel in the staircase. She knew he’d broken Augusta’s favorite vase and blamed the gardener. And she knew about the little wooden boat he made when he was twelve.”
Jessica remembered that boat. Thomas had kept it on a shelf in his study for years.
“He told me his father made it,” she said.
Caroline shook her head.
“Margaret said she helped him.”
Jessica looked away.
She had always thought of Thomas’s childhood as a collection of stories he’d chosen to share with her. Now she was beginning to understand how much of it he’d left unexplained.
“Did Margaret tell you what happened to her?”
“Some of it.”
Caroline drew a slow breath.
“She said Augusta brought her to Wisteria Lane when she was young. She’d been promised work as a companion, but Augusta was interested in spiritualism and believed an old mirror upstairs could preserve a person’s life.”
Jessica looked at her daughter.
“A mirror?”
“The large one in the sitting room. The one Dad never wanted us near.”
Jessica remembered it vaguely: a tall, dark-framed mirror that had stood against the far wall, its glass clouded around the edges.
“She said Augusta used it to make another Margaret,” Caroline continued. “The woman who had come to work for her died during the ceremony. The one who walked away had the same memories, the same voice, even the same fear. She knew she was a copy, but she was still a person. Augusta made her answer to Augusta’s name when she stood before the glass. She never stopped thinking of herself as Margaret.”
Jessica remained silent.
“Margaret told me she was the second one.”
The waitress approached with fresh tea. Jessica waited until she’d gone before speaking.
“Caroline, you understand how extraordinary that sounds.”
“Yes.”
“Did you ever see this mirror do anything?”
“No. Not at first.”
Jessica appreciated the honesty.
“Then how did you come to believe her?”
Caroline took a long time to answer.
“Because I watched her change.”
The changes had begun gradually.
Caroline described how Margaret’s gray hair had darkened, how the shape of her face had altered, and how she’d become increasingly distressed whenever she caught sight of herself in a reflective surface.
“She stopped looking in mirrors altogether,” Caroline said. “She covered the one in the sitting room with a sheet.”
Jessica thought of the woman in the coffin.
“Did she begin to look like me?”
“Yes.”
“When?”
“During the summer. At first, it was just little things. Her mouth, the shape of her nose. Then I realized she was beginning to resemble you.”
“Then a scar appeared on her chin, in exactly the place where you have yours. And in September I noticed a little crescent at her hairline. It was mine, Mom. I showed Margaret the mark on my own forehead, and she cried. She thought the ring was drawing on the people closest to the woman it had been given to replace. It had been Jessica’s ring, but Caroline had carried it to the house and handled it every day. Margaret said the glass was borrowing what it could from both of them, even the small mark Caroline had had since birth. Neither woman knew whether that was the whole explanation, and the thought frightened them more than a simple resemblance would have.”
Jessica looked at her daughter.
“Why didn’t you tell me?”
Caroline’s expression crumpled.
“Because Margaret said the mirror had chosen you.”
Jessica felt a cold sensation settle beneath her ribs.
“Chosen me for what?”
“To replace her.”
Caroline reached into her bag again and removed a folded sheet of paper.
It was a copy of one of Thomas’s letters, written to Henry Wescott several years before his death.
Jessica recognized the handwriting.
I will not allow Jessica to become part of this arrangement. Whatever Augusta promised, she had no right to bind another person to it.
You have told me repeatedly that there is no alternative. I refuse to accept that.
Margaret has suffered enough. So has everyone else who has been forced to live with this secret.
I intend to find another way.
Jessica read the letter twice.
She remembered Thomas sitting at his desk late at night, writing letters he never seemed willing to discuss. She had assumed they concerned the house or his father’s estate.
She’d never imagined he was trying to protect her from something like this.
“Did he know about the mirror when we married?” she asked.
“I don’t think so.”
Jessica looked at the letter again.
“He gave me his grandmother’s wedding ring.”
Caroline nodded.
“I found references to it in the papers. Margaret said Augusta used it when she first made the bargain.”
Jessica remembered the ring on the woman’s finger at Bellamy Funeral Home.
The engraving had always seemed romantic.
Forever, even after.
She’d worn it for years without knowing its history.
“Did you take it from my jewelry box?” she asked.
Caroline lowered her eyes.
“Yes.”
“When?”
“In August. I was at the house one afternoon while you were at the shop.”
Jessica stared at her.
“You were in my home?”
“I knew you wouldn’t be there.”
“That isn’t the point.”
“I know.”
Jessica took a breath.
She had so many reasons to be angry with her daughter that she hardly knew which to address first.
“Why did you need the ring?”
“Margaret thought it might help us undo the connection. She remembered Augusta using it during the original ritual.”
Jessica looked at her.
“And did it?”
Caroline shook her head.
“Not the way we hoped.”
Jessica waited.
“Margaret wanted to leave Wisteria Lane. She’d been trapped there for so long, Mom. She couldn’t even remember what it felt like to walk through the city.”
Caroline’s voice softened.
“She asked me whether the old market was still there. Whether people still sold flowers near the square. She remembered Savannah from a time neither of us had ever known.”
Jessica imagined the woman sitting beside the upstairs window, listening to a city changing beyond her reach.
“Did she know leaving might kill her?”
“Yes.”
“Then why did she go?”
Caroline looked at her.
“Because she was tired of being afraid.”
Jessica said nothing.
Caroline explained that they’d waited until Sunday evening. She’d helped Margaret downstairs, wrapped her in a coat, and taken her out through the rear entrance.
For a few minutes, everything had seemed ordinary.
Margaret had stood in the garden looking at the trees, breathing the evening air. She’d asked Caroline to tell her about the city and whether the river still smelled of salt after a storm.
Then she’d begun to tremble.
Caroline had tried to help her back inside, but Margaret collapsed before they reached the door.
“I called for an ambulance,” Caroline said. “Then I remembered what she’d told me about the mirror, and I panicked. I canceled the call.”
Jessica looked at her sharply.
“Caroline.”
“I know. I should have let them come.”
“Yes, you should.”
“I thought if they took her away, something worse might happen. I didn’t know what was real anymore.”
Caroline began twisting the napkin in her lap.
“I called Henry. He came to the house and examined her. He said there was one way to release her, but we had to act quickly.”
Jessica felt anger rise again.
“What did he tell you?”
“That Margaret had to be buried under your name.”
Jessica stared at her.
“And you believed him?”
“He showed me papers Dad had left. He said the mirror could only recognize one identity at a time, and that if Margaret was buried as Jessica Marsh, the connection would end.”
“Did he explain what would happen to me?”
“He said you’d be safe because you were still alive.”
Jessica looked at her daughter for a long moment.
Caroline began to cry.
“I know how terrible it sounds.”
“It doesn’t just sound terrible, Caroline. You arranged a funeral for your living mother.”
“I thought I was saving you.”
Jessica looked away.
She remembered the radio announcement, the drive to Bellamy Funeral Home, and the sight of her own face lying motionless in the coffin.
She remembered Margaret opening her eyes.
Don’t let her bury me.
The warning had not been a plea to escape death.
It had been a warning against what Henry intended to do afterward.
Jessica looked back at Caroline.
“Margaret spoke to me.”
Caroline went very still.
“What?”
“At the funeral home. She opened her eyes and told me not to let her be buried.”
Caroline’s face drained of color.
“She was still there?”
“For a moment.”
Caroline covered her mouth.
Jessica reached across the table.
“Sweetheart, I don’t think Henry told you the truth.”
Caroline looked at her through tears.
“I don’t either.”




