Chapter Three: For Better or Considerably Worse
Nick arrived in the library still adjusting his tie. At thirty-seven, he was as handsome as Penny remembered, with the same habit of tugging at his collar whenever he was nervous. For a second, she was back in their old kitchen waiting for him to find his keys.
“Tessa said there was a problem,” he said. “Ivy, what’s going on?”
Ivy stood beside the fireplace, holding her bouquet as though it were the only thing keeping her upright. “I need to tell you something about how we met.”
Nick glanced at Penny. “Why is Penny here?”
“Because I asked her,” Ivy said. “Please listen before you decide anything.”
She told Nick her former name, what happened at Harbor Reach, and why she’d gone to the fundraiser where they met. Twice she had to start again. He listened until she admitted she’d approached him because of Patrick.
“You went looking for me,” he said.
“Yes.”
“Because you wanted information about my best friend.”
“At first.”
Nick looked toward the windows, then back at her. “How much of our relationship was real?”
“All the parts after I realized I wanted to be with you. I know that’s a terrible answer.”
“It isn’t an answer I can trust.”
Nick looked bewildered and hurt. Penny was glad she hadn’t spoken for Ivy.
“Why today?” he asked.
“Patrick recognized me. He threatened to tell you how we met if I said anything about Harbor Reach.” Ivy showed him the message. “I should have told you before any of this. I wanted to, and I kept choosing another day.”
Nick read the text twice. “He sent you this?”
“Yes.”
A knock interrupted them. Patrick entered without waiting for an answer, followed by Tessa, who had clearly decided that if she couldn’t stop him she could at least witness the attempt.
“The guests are being seated,” Patrick said. “I assume somebody has a good explanation for the disappearing bride.”
Nick held up the phone. “Did you send this to Ivy?”
Patrick’s gaze flicked to the screen. “Nick, this is not the time.”
“Did you?”
“I was trying to spare you an embarrassment.” He looked at Ivy with an expression of injured patience. “She’s not who you think she is. She came into your life with a plan, and now she’s making accusations about me because she’s afraid you’ll find out.”
“You knew her before yesterday?” Nick asked.
Patrick shifted. “I suspected something when I first saw her picture. I had someone check. I wanted to be certain before I upset you.”
“That’s not what you told me at the rehearsal,” Ivy said.
“I didn’t tell you anything at the rehearsal except that we should talk.”
“Then why call me Mae?”
Patrick’s silence did more than an angry denial could have. Nick looked again at the message, then at his friend.
“You’ve known for months,” he said.
“I was protecting you.”
“You threatened my fiancée on the morning of our wedding.”
“Your fiancée lied to you.”
“She did,” Nick said. “I’m talking to her about that. I’m asking you why you thought you could decide what I was allowed to know.”
For once, Patrick couldn’t seem to talk his way out.
Penny stepped forward. “You did the same thing when I raised those invoice questions, remember? You told Nick they were clerical errors and made the whole argument about me being difficult.”
“Not this again,” Patrick said.
“It’s not an argument I’m asking to reopen. It’s a pattern you’re demonstrating in front of us.” Penny glanced at Nick. “But you should know I didn’t bring a secret file to the wedding. I can’t prove Patrick stole anything. Neither can Ivy. What we can prove is that he tried to keep her quiet.”
Nick looked at her with a recognition that was almost painful. “I didn’t believe you then.”
“No,” she said. “You didn’t.”
He turned back to Patrick. “I want you to leave.”
“You’ll regret this. You’re letting two women with grudges turn your wedding into a circus.”
“The wedding is already a circus,” Tessa said. “I’ve been explaining to Aunt Denise for half an hour that the bride isn’t required to wear her grandmother’s veil. Please don’t make me handle an actual fistfight.”
“Tessa,” Nick said gently.
“I’m coping. Ask me again after I’ve canceled the string quartet.” She held the door open and gave Patrick a look that left little room for negotiation.
He left without another word.
Outside the library came the murmur of a hundred people who believed a wedding was about to begin.
Ivy set her bouquet on the mantel. “I can still walk out there,” she told Nick. “If you want to call it off in front of everyone, I won’t stop you.”
“I don’t want to humiliate you.” His voice was tired. “I love you. That’s why this is so difficult.”
“I love you too.”
“Then why didn’t you trust me enough to tell me?”
“Because I saw what happened when Penny tried.” Ivy swallowed. “And because each day I kept quiet made the next day harder. I thought if I could just get to the wedding, everything before it would somehow stop mattering.”
Nick sat in a leather chair, still holding her phone. “I can’t marry you today.”
Ivy closed her eyes, then nodded. It wasn’t a dramatic collapse, and Penny was grateful for that. It was simply a woman receiving a consequence she’d spent a year trying not to face.
“I don’t know what happens after today,” Nick continued. “I want to hear everything. I want to know what happened at that charity, and what Patrick has been doing in our business. But I can’t make vows while I’m wondering how many things we haven’t told each other.”
“That’s fair,” Ivy said, her voice small.
Tessa told the planner there would be no ceremony, but the food and bar could still be served. The guests would hear only that the wedding had been postponed for personal reasons. Tessa muttered about invoicing the family for emotional damages.
Before Penny left the room, Nick touched her arm.
“I owe you an apology,” he said. “Not because of what happened today. Because eighteen months ago, you showed me something that worried you, and I made it about whether you trusted my judgment. I never really listened.”
Penny abandoned the speeches she’d imagined giving him since their breakup.
“Thank you,” she said. “I needed to hear that.”
“Can we talk again sometime?”
“Maybe. But not today.”
He nodded, accepting it. That was new, and rather nice.
By five-thirty, the guests were eating dinner and speculating quietly. Aunt Denise had asked whether the postponement affected the cake.
Penny found Adam on the terrace, putting a lens into his bag. The rain had passed, leaving the garden smelling of wet stone and roses. Through the glass she could see guests reaching for the bread baskets as if civilization itself depended on them.
“I heard there was no ceremony,” Adam said.
“There was a meaningful exchange of views. The paperwork’s been postponed.”
He laughed. “Tessa told me you helped. She also told me not to ask for details.”
“Good advice. I only disclose wedding secrets in exchange for excellent coffee.”
“That sounds negotiable.” He zipped the bag and studied her for a moment. “Would you let me buy you one sometime? Not here. Somewhere the bride and groom are statistically unlikely to appear.”
Penny looked down at her shoes, now openly hostile. Adam seemed kind, and funny without needing an audience. He hadn’t tried to make himself the hero of somebody else’s bad day.
“I’d like that,” she said. “Provided there’s seating and nobody expects me to wear these shoes.”
“Comfortable shoes are encouraged. I know a place with good cinnamon rolls.”
“Now you’re leading with your strongest argument.”
They exchanged numbers. He promised to call next week.
As Penny walked to her car, she saw her reflection in the dark window of the conservatory. The dress was still beautiful. Her hair had survived the weather, just about. She’d arrived hoping Nick would see how completely she’d moved on, as though moving on required a witness and a good seat near the front.
Now she wasn’t thinking about whether he’d noticed. She was thinking about cinnamon rolls, and about a woman in a wedding dress who’d finally told the truth. She hoped Ivy and Nick found something honest, together or apart.
She slid into the driver’s seat and took off her shoes before turning the key. Whatever happened next, she intended to be comfortable for it.




