Chapter Two: A Very Inconvenient Friendship
By November, Alice had developed a routine. She worked from nine until late afternoon, went back to the small apartment she had rented above a bakery in town, and returned to the library whenever an especially stubborn puzzle refused to leave her alone. Lucius complained about her hours but never told her to stop. In fact, he began leaving books open to relevant pages and arranging fresh pencils beside her worktable, gestures so unobtrusive that she might have missed them if she hadn’t been trained to notice tiny changes in familiar objects.
She learned that he disliked television, considered the phrase content creator an offense against language, and regarded the electric heater in the library with an almost personal hostility.
“It hums,” he told her one evening, staring at the appliance.
“That’s generally how electric heaters announce they’re working.”
“Men have been executed for less persistent noises.”
“I’m guessing your customer reviews are terrible.”
He looked at her, and the corner of his mouth moved. Alice grinned before he could hide it.
Their conversations became a peculiar pleasure. She told him about growing up outside Boston, her mother’s habit of saving every birthday card, and the museum job she’d left after a director decided that “digital engagement” mattered more than conserving the actual objects. Lucius listened with an attentiveness she had rarely encountered. He never glanced at a phone, interrupted to tell a better story, or pretended to understand something he did not.
In return, he offered fragments of his own past. He had traveled widely, studied languages, and lived in several countries. He spoke of Prague, Vienna, and Paris with the fond exasperation of a man discussing difficult relatives. But whenever Alice asked about his family, he grew guarded.
One stormy evening, the power failed while she was cataloging a bundle of letters. Rain battered the windows, and the library sank into a darkness so complete that Alice nearly knocked a glass of water over a two-hundred-year-old diary.
“Perfect,” she said into the blackness. “Exactly what the preservation guidelines recommend.”
A flame appeared in the doorway. Lucius stood holding a candle, its light sharpening the planes of his face.
“Afraid of the dark, Miss Morgan?”
“Only when I’m surrounded by irreplaceable manuscripts and a man who looks like he might own a coffin.”
“I own several.”
She waited for the smile that would reveal the joke. He remained solemn until she laughed, at which point his expression softened so unexpectedly that she felt a small, disconcerting flutter beneath her ribs.
They moved to the sitting room, where a wood fire had survived the outage. Alice sat cross-legged on the rug with a mug of tea while Lucius occupied a chair beside the hearth, looking faintly scandalized by her disregard for furniture. Beyond the windows, the Atlantic roared against the rocks below the estate.
“Why do you live here alone?” she asked after a while.
“Because I have found that people are easier to appreciate at a distance.”
“That sounds like something a man says when he’s trying not to admit he’s lonely.”
He watched the fire. “People leave, Alice. Eventually, they all do.”
“Some people leave because they want to. Some don’t get a choice.”
“No,” he said quietly. “They don’t.”
She thought of Isolde’s portrait and understood that she had wandered into a grief far older than she could imagine. For a moment she wanted to reach across the space between them, but his stillness warned her against it.
“You know,” she said instead, “for someone who owns so much history, you’re remarkably determined not to have a future.”
Lucius lifted his gaze. He looked almost wounded, and she regretted the words until he spoke.
“You should go home.”
“Did I offend you?”
“Not at all. That’s rather the difficulty.” He rose, setting his untouched tea on the mantel. “I’m beginning to look forward to your company.”
Alice stood too. “And that’s a problem?”
He glanced toward the dark hallway that led to the library and its portrait. “A very serious one.”
She left shortly afterward, but his strange admission followed her into the cold Maine night. Alice had no intention of falling for a man who treated kindness as a hazard. She told herself so while brushing her teeth, again while setting her alarm, and once more the next morning when she found herself smiling at the prospect of seeing him.
Two weeks later, she learned why he had been afraid.
She had stayed late to finish an inventory and was searching for a missing reference ledger when she found an old drawer standing slightly open in the study. She would later tell herself that she had only meant to close it. That explanation became less convincing when she discovered a photograph of Lucius standing beside a motorcar in 1923.
At first, she assumed it showed his grandfather. Then she found another, dated 1889, with the same pale eyes and distinctive face. Beneath it lay a small portrait photograph of a young couple, taken in June 1878. The woman was unmistakably Isolde. The man beside her was Lucius, unchanged down to the angle of his smile.
Alice stood motionless, the photograph trembling slightly between her fingers. The dates could be wrong, the pictures could have been altered, and family resemblance could explain a great deal. None of those possibilities explained the handwriting on the back: Lucius and Isolde Vale, our first summer in Maine.
“You weren’t supposed to find those.”
Lucius stood in the doorway. He didn’t look angry. Somehow, that made the moment worse.
“Who are you?” Alice asked.
He studied the photograph in her hand. “Someone who should have died a very long time ago.”




